Picture a budget meeting next month. Two team leads, Priya and Dan, walk in one after the other. Each runs a team that costs $100,000 a quarter. Each spent another $10,000 on AI tools. Each has a slide showing that almost everyone on the team uses AI every day, and each asks for more money next year.
You have to pick who gets it, and from those two slides you can't. They look the same.
They aren't the same. One of these teams is now paying more for every piece of work it finishes than it did before AI arrived. Neither slide shows it, and neither Priya nor Dan is hiding anything. Nobody has asked them for the number that would.
The sum that tells them apart
It takes a minute, and it needs one idea: a piece of work. That's one finished item of whatever a team produces. It could be a customer problem solved, a feature delivered, a deal closed or an invoice processed.
Before AI, both teams cost $100,000 a quarter and finished 100 pieces of work, so each piece cost $1,000. Then each team added $10,000 of AI.
Same AI spend, opposite results
A made-up example with round numbers, to show the sum.
| Before AI | Priya's team | Dan's team | |
|---|---|---|---|
| People cost | $100,000 | $100,000 | $100,000 |
| AI cost | $0 | $10,000 | $10,000 |
| Pieces of work finished | 100 | 120 | 100 |
| Cost of each piece | $1,000 | $9178% cheaper | $1,10010% more expensive |
Priya's team now finishes 120 pieces, so each one costs $917. Dan's team still finishes 100, so each one costs $1,100. That's 8% cheaper for one team and 10% more expensive for the other, from the same spend and the same slide.
If you run a team, you're already objecting, and you're right to. Pieces of work aren't all the same size. A team that gets funded on the count will start cutting its work into smaller pieces. And cheaper only matters if the extra 20 pieces were work the company wanted, done as well as before.
So count only work that someone accepted, whether that's a customer or another team. Check that the amount of work sent back to be redone didn't go up. Then ask what the extra work was worth, which is the second question further down.
Even with all that care, you now know something the slides couldn't tell you. Priya has earned a serious look at more money. Dan needs help before he gets any.
Why this meeting is happening everywhere
Companies spent about $33 billion on AI last year. This year it's $177 billion, more than five times as much. That's the count from Menlo Ventures, an investment firm that publishes it every year. I can't think of another line in a company budget that has grown like that without the CFO asking, in writing, what came back.
And what did come back? McKinsey, the consulting firm, asked people across many companies this summer. Eight out of ten said AI makes them faster at their own job. Only 37% said it had added anything to their company's operating profit, which is the money a business makes from its day-to-day work. That share was the same a year ago.
That's Priya and Dan's meeting, repeated in thousands of companies. Almost everyone feels faster, and most companies can't yet see it in the money.
We see it up close as well. At one of the larger companies we work with, keeping this record showed two things no usage slide could.
The first was about cost. AI tools run on different models, and some cost many times more than others. A large part of this company's AI bill was going to the most expensive ones, for everyday work that a cheaper one does just as well.
The second was about people. The teams getting the most done weren't the ones using AI the most. They used less of it and used it better, and once that was visible, other teams could learn how they worked. Nobody had hidden any of this. Nobody had been asked to look.
Who's getting results
It would be easy to conclude that AI isn't paying off. I don't think that's right any more. BCG, another consulting firm, reported this year that almost half of companies now get value from AI. That fits with McKinsey's number. The value is turning up in parts of the business before it turns up in the overall profit.
So some companies are pulling ahead, and I wanted to know if they'd simply spent more. They hadn't. The winners spend plenty, but so does everyone else. BCG found back in 2024 that the leading companies try about half as many AI projects as the rest. They also keep count.
Wharton, the business school, ran a survey with the research firm GBK this summer. It asked leaders how sure they are of what their company spends on AI in total, and then compared how each group was doing.
The ones who keep count are the ones who see results.
Share of leaders who say AI is paying off strongly for them.
View as table
| Group | Say AI is paying off strongly |
|---|---|
| Less sure what they spend on AI in total | 10% |
| Very sure what they spend on AI in total | 56% |
| Team counts only time and cost saved | 13% |
| Team also counts what the work brought in | 35% |
Leaders who are very sure what they spend say AI is paying off strongly 56% of the time. For the rest, it's 10%. The lower pair matters too. Counting only the time and cost saved isn't enough, and the teams doing best also count what the work brought in.
A fair warning: this is a survey, and people are grading their own results. Wharton says itself that leaders who feel sure about their spending tend to feel good about AI in general. I'm also not telling anyone to spend less. But the pattern matches what the sum showed. The companies getting results can say where the money went and what came back.
The mistake isn't spending on AI. It's spending without keeping a record, because then next year's budget goes to whoever tells the best story.